Homemade Spice Blend Gift Jars: 3 Easy Mixes for Neighbors, Hosts, and Coworkers
Homemade spice blends are one of those gifts that look special but come together at the kitchen counter in a few minutes. In this post I’m sharing three easy mixes: a cozy mulling spice bag for cider, a salt-free herb blend for roasting, and a jar of cinnamon sugar for toast and oatmeal.
All three are dry, shelf-stable blends, so you can make them ahead and give them to neighbors, hosts, coworkers, or anyone on your list. I’d start with one jar to see how you like the process, then add the others to build a set.
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Content on Life With Amanda is created with the help of AI.
What You Will Need
- Small glass jars with white lids: 4 oz jars, straight-sided and clear, for the herb blend and the cinnamon sugar
- Kraft labels: kraft labels for ingredients and directions
- Gift tags and twine: kraft tags with natural jute twine
- Muslin drawstring bags: muslin bags, 3 x 4 inches, for the mulling spices
- Small funnel: spice funnel for filling jars without spills
- Cinnamon sticks: cinnamon sticks
- Whole cloves: whole cloves
- Whole allspice berries: whole allspice
- Star anise: star anise
- Dried rosemary: dried rosemary
- Dried thyme: dried thyme
- Rubbed sage: rubbed sage
- Garlic powder: garlic powder
- Ground cinnamon: ground cinnamon
- Granulated sugar: granulated sugar
- Small wooden gift box: unfinished wooden boxes, 8 x 8 x 3 inches, to hold a set of two jars and a mulling bag
- Red satin ribbon: satin ribbon
- White tissue paper: tissue paper for lining the box
Before You Start: Jars, Labels, and Freshness
Wash the jars and lids in hot soapy water, then let them dry completely. Even a little moisture can make herbs clump and sugar harden, so I’d let them air dry for a few hours or wipe them out with a clean dry towel.
Fresher spices taste better, so check the dates on your jars and choose the newest ones you have. Whole spices keep their flavor the longest, which is why the mulling blend uses them.
1. Cozy Mulling Spice Bags

These are meant to be dropped into warm apple cider, so the spices stay whole and go in a muslin bag. This recipe fills one bag, and you can multiply it for as many gifts as you need.
Per bag:
- 2 cinnamon sticks, broken in half to fit
- 1 tablespoon whole allspice berries
- 1 teaspoon whole cloves
- 2 star anise
- Combine the spices in a small bowl.
- Spoon them into a muslin bag and pull the drawstring tight.
- Tie on a kraft tag with twine and write the directions on the back.
Directions for the recipient: Add one bag to about 8 cups of apple cider along with a few strips of fresh orange peel. Simmer on low for 15 to 20 minutes, then remove the bag. The spices are for flavoring only and are not meant to be eaten.
2. Salt-Free Holiday Herb Blend

This savory blend is a good match for roasted chicken, pork, and potatoes. Leaving out the salt lets the person you give it to season the dish the way they like.
Fills one 4 oz jar:
- 2 tablespoons dried rosemary, lightly crushed
- 2 tablespoons dried thyme
- 1 tablespoon rubbed sage
- 1 tablespoon garlic powder
- Stir everything together in a dry bowl.
- Set the funnel in the jar and spoon the blend in.
- Tap the jar gently to settle the herbs, then close the lid.
Directions for the recipient: Use about 1 tablespoon per pound of chicken, pork, or potatoes. Add salt, oil, or butter to taste before roasting.
To make four jars at once, multiply the recipe by four and mix it in a large bowl.
3. Cinnamon Sugar for Toast and Oatmeal

This is the simplest blend of the three, and it works well for anyone who likes a sweet morning. Stir it into oatmeal, sprinkle it over buttered toast, or add a spoonful to coffee.
Fills one 4 oz jar:
- 6 tablespoons granulated sugar
- 1 tablespoon ground cinnamon
- Whisk the sugar and cinnamon together until the color is even.
- Funnel the mix into the jar and leave a little space at the top.
- Put on the lid and give the jar a good shake to blend it one more time.
Labeling Your Jars
A good label does three jobs. It names the blend, lists every ingredient, and tells the recipient how to use it. Write the date you made it on the bottom so they know how fresh it is.
Because these are gifts, I’d always list each ingredient so anyone with a food allergy can check before using. Add a short line like “Mulling spices, not for eating” on the bag tag so nobody mistakes it for a snack mix.
Packing a Gift Set

One jar is a nice host gift, and a set of three feels extra generous. Line a small wooden box with white tissue paper, nestle in the two jars and the mulling bag, and tie a red satin ribbon around the outside. A sprig of fresh rosemary tucked beside the jars adds a festive touch.
How to Store Your Blends
Keep the jars in a cool, dark place away from the stove and sunlight. A good rule of thumb is to enjoy the herb blend and cinnamon sugar within about 6 months, while the whole spices in the mulling bags keep their flavor for up to about a year.
Gift Ideas for Every Name on Your List
- Neighbors: A single jar of cinnamon sugar with a tag and twine.
- Hosts: The mulling bag tucked next to a bottle of apple cider.
- Coworkers: A jar of herb blend with a handwritten recipe card for roasted potatoes.
- Teachers: The full gift box set.
Final Thoughts
Spice blends are an easy way to give something handmade without a long project. Mix a few jars this weekend, add a pretty label, and you’ll have gifts ready to hand out. If you want more ideas, browse these handmade gift ideas and these teacher gift baskets.